Buttercup Dairy Store
Project Overview
Buttercup’s Dairy Store is a beloved local grocery store in Port Jefferson, Long Island, with deep roots in the community dating back to the 1930s. Now run by the fourth generation of family owners, Buttercup’s has grown from a small dairy farm into a neighborhood staple known for its in-house baked goods, fresh pies, and personal service.
As fellow Long Island small business owners, they came to us looking for a website design partner that understood their community, values, and customer base.
The task was to create a custom WordPress website that captures the heritage and personality of Buttercup’s Dairy Store while making it simple for the team to showcase daily specials, fresh baked goods, and seasonal products.
The strategy was centered around clarity, ease of use, and community connection. Buttercup’s customer base ranges widely in age and tech comfort, so the site needed to be highly accessible, easy to navigate, and visually clear on both desktop and mobile.
We also structured the content with SEO in mind. Each product and category page is optimized to boost search visibility — especially important as they continue to expand their online offerings and add new baked goods and grocery items to the site.
The design strikes a balance between nostalgic and modern. We maintained Buttercup’s old-world feel using warm tones, serif fonts, and traditional design elements — but layered in modern functionality and clean navigation to make the site intuitive for users of all ages.
Special attention was given to product photography and daily specials, with clear sections for fresh pies, in-house bakery items, and seasonal offerings. The result is a warm, welcoming digital storefront that matches the in-person experience Buttercup’s customers have loved for generations.
We built Buttercup’s site to be straightforward, scalable, and uniquely theirs. It allows them to update products and specials easily, helping the site stay fresh and relevant. Every feature — from the homepage layout to the individual product pages — was designed with their audience and business goals in mind.
Built to reflect Buttercup’s heritage and local reputation.
Easy-to-update sections for baked goods and grocery highlights.
Each product helps increase visibility in search results.
Designed for accessibility across tech comfort levels.
Since launching the new website, Buttercup’s Dairy Store has seen improved SEO performance, with individual products helping drive organic traffic. Their team is now able to easily update daily specials and add new items, keeping the website fresh and relevant to regular and new customers alike. The design reflects their brand’s history while giving them the modern functionality needed to grow in the digital space.
For project inquiries only:
contact@artofmediadesign.com
For other questions:
info@artofmediadesign.com